top of page

Publications

Selected publications. More information on Eran’s Google Scholar Profile or CRIS profile.

Despite extensive investment in smart city infrastructure, adoption remains uneven across urban populations. While existing research has examined individual demographic factors influencing smart city adoption, the role of neighborhood-level context as a distinct determinant remains underexplored. This study addresses this gap by investigating how neighborhood residency, beyond individual demographics, shapes engagement with municipal digital technologies. Using data from a representative telephone survey (n = 489) across four socioeconomically diverse neighborhoods in Tel Aviv, we tested whether neighborhood context provides explanatory power beyond demographic variables alone. Using structural equation modeling (SEM), we found that including neighborhoods in the adoption model improves model fit by nearly 20 percentage points relative to a model including only demographic factors. Neighborhood residency is associated with the use of digital services, technological proficiency (TP), and privacy concerns (PC), which, in turn, mediate attitudes toward smart city adoption. These attitudes were then correlated with administrative data on the use of municipal smart city services. An additional analysis revealed that, although user-facing digital services exhibit similar socioeconomic gradients, municipality-led infrastructure (e.g., bike-sharing) shows a more equitable distribution, suggesting distinct equity dynamics across smart city service types. We conclude the paper by suggesting that neighborhoods can be treated as the central unit for studying, designing, and deploying smart city technologies.

Place Matters: The Role of Neighborhoods in Adopting Smart City Services

Toch, Eran, and Shahaf Donio

Journal of Urban Technology 1-31

33(3)

2026

Android applications (i.e., apps) are indispensable nowadays and are getting bigger and bigger with an increasing number of functionalities. To understand how to access functionalities in an app, prior studies proposed tools to model the transitions between functionalities with the activity transition graph (ATG). ATG is an important data structure and has been used for various Android app analyses, including app design, understanding, and testing. However, there is no benchmarking work on ATG generation. It is still unclear whether the transitions identified by tools are correct and how many transitions are missed. To fill this gap, we manually identified all transitions in 98 applications to build a benchmark. Using the benchmark, we evaluate seven popular ATG generation tools that were used in prior studies. We observe that these tools not only report incorrect transitions but also miss transitions, and different tools do not report the same set of transitions. Compared with the transitions reported by a single tool, the union set of the transitions reported by different tools contains fewer missed transitions but more incorrect transitions. We summarize five potential reasons that explain why GUI testing tools fail to identify transitions in ATG, revealing the limitations in the current design of exploration strategies. For instance, we observe that learning-based tools may overlook subtle distinctions between states, potentially misclassifying different states as identical. This will lead the tool to always focus on the old state while the new state is not fully explored. Based on our findings, we propose a series of suggestions for researchers using and building ATG generation tools. For example, when aiming to identify more transitions, one can combine the results of different tools by running each tool for 10 minutes, which will produce better results than running a single tool for 60 minutes.

Activity Transition Graph Generation: How Far Are We?

Liu, Jiakun, Peixin Zhang, Han Hu, Yonghui Liu, Wei Minn, Ferdian Thung, Shahar Maoz, Eran Toch, Debin Gao, and David Lo

ACM Transactions on Software Engineering and Methodology

35(7)

2026

Purpose Digitising historical resources has become a critical step in historical research, augmenting manual processes and facilitating big data studies. However, older material is of lower quality and may affect the quality of the digitisation. We document and quantify this bias in the context of a trademark registry reconstruction project, which involves identifying and matching graphical trademarks from notifications published in the Official Gazette during the British Mandate in Palestine (1917–1948). Design/methodology/approach We develop a rule-based pipeline combining graphical object extraction and optical character recognition (OCR) to match trademark images to metadata records across more than 300 Gazette editions, spanning 26 years. To measure the temporal dimension of digitisation quality, logistic regression is applied to the full dataset of 7,263 trademarks to isolate the effect of publication date on matching probability, independently of structural layout changes. Findings The pipeline achieves an overall identification rate of 86.6%. Using logistic regression, we find a statistically significant temporal effect: each additional year is associated with a 0.38 percentage-point increase in matching probability, corresponding to approximately 13% improvement over the 26-year study period. The decline in accuracy for 1920s editions is attributable to physical paper deterioration and scan quality rather than structural layout changes. Research limitations/implications The pipeline is tailored to the Palestine Gazette’s specific conventions and relies on commercial OCR software, which limits direct replicability without adaptation. The study draws on a single jurisdiction and source type, so the magnitude of chronological bias may differ across other corpora. Practical implications The rule-based extraction and matching pipeline provides a replicable, low-threshold tool for analogous digitisation projects, including other colonial trademark or patent registries and official gazettes, without requiring advanced machine-learning infrastructure. The reconstructed British Mandate trademark registry, now openly available, enables historical and comparative research on commercial activity, legal history and colonial governance. The finding of a chronological bias urges digitisation project managers to incorporate temporal bias measurement into quality-assurance workflows and to stratify or weight findings by publication period rather than aggregating results uniformly across time. Originality/value Our research reveals that the deteriorating efficiency of a newspaper-analysing algorithm over time may lead to a chronological bias, skewing historical data towards more recent periods, a critical factor we aim to document and highlight to support more accurate and balanced historical research. The research tool we developed facilitates similar digitisation projects for trademarks and other images, along with their accompanying information. This is a necessary step in reconstructing old or lost trademark registries, which can then contribute to understanding the economic and cultural dimensions of the relevant jurisdiction.

Temporal bias in historical newspaper digitisation: evidence from reconstructing the British mandate trademark registry

Eran Toch, Bar Ifrah, and Michael Birnhack

Journal of Documentation 1-19

82(4)

2026

Differential Privacy (DP) has emerged as the standard for privacy-preserving analysis of individual-level data. Despite growing attention in the research community to the operationalization of DP through the selection of the privacy budget ɛ , little is known about how DP obfuscation affects users’ disclosure decisions in data market scenarios. These decisions may be context-specific and vary with privacy preferences, eliciting disparate data valuations across individuals. Through a choice-based conjoint analysis ( N 1 = 588 ), simulating realistic data markets, we analyzed how varying DP protection levels influence individual decision-making of participation in data collection under DP. Our findings show that personal reward and the guaranteed DP protection had the strongest influence on participants’ selection of a data collection scenario. Surprisingly, the type of disclosed data had the least influence on participants’ decisions to disclose personal data, a trend consistent across participants from different countries. Furthermore, increasing the DP protection level by a single unit reduced the preferred compensation price by over 60% for the same level of user utility, with marginal effects diminishing exponentially at higher DP levels. Our results were then confirmed in an online study ( N 2 = 146 ) involving real data disclosure with actual payments, using our original scenario framing. Our findings can support context-specific DP configuration and help data practitioners improve decision-making associated with privacy protection in differentially private systems, balancing the trade-off between DP and compensation costs.

Investigating the impact of differential privacy obfuscation on users’ data disclosure decisions

Michael Khavkin and Eran Toch

Decision Support Systems

196

2025

Following the introduction of ChatGPT 3.5, the first widely available general-purpose large language model, users were able to experiment and interact with this new AI technology at scale for the first time. This study investigates the appropriation of the discourse on algorithmic bias by conservative users with respect to ChatGPT, particularly on the social media platform X (formerly Twitter), during the initial months following ChatGPT’s public release (February–June 2023). Through a mixed-method analysis of user-generated ‘experiments’ with ChatGPT and a digital ethnography of X discourse, we explore how conservative users have repurposed the concept of ‘algorithmic bias’, originally grounded in liberal values, to advance their ideological agendas. This phenomenon, which we analyze as a form of ‘discourse hijacking’, reveals a critical divergence in how liberal and conservative critiques engage with the notion of power. While liberal critiques are embedded in a critical theory framework that emphasizes structural inequalities and systemic power imbalances, conservative critiques often disregard these dimensions and instead focus on perceived biases against hegemonic groups. Our findings reveal distinct differences between the liberal and conservative critiques of ChatGPT, not only in content but also in the strategies employed, with a mixture of thematic strategies (such as adopting a mocking or playful tone) and coordinated social media actions. These findings underscore the complex relationship between political orientation and public discourse on emerging technologies.

Hijacking algorithmic bias: analyzing the political discourse around ChatGPT on social media

Maayan Cohen and Eran Toch

Information, Communication & Society 1-26

29(4)

2025

An increasing number of technologies depend on the large-scale collection of individual-level data, whether for gathering statistical insights from billions of users or training AI models. However, reliance on personal data raises privacy concerns that, in turn, limit the collection and analysis essential to these technologies. Differential Privacy (DP) has gained traction in both academia and industry, ensuring privacy by adding carefully crafted noise to data or its outputs based on a pre-defined DP parameter$\varepsilon$. As real-world implementations emerge, we can examine how DP is practically used beyond academic settings, supporting industry adoption and expanding knowledge on DP applications. Using a systematic process, we comprehensively surveyed the deployed parameters of DP configurations in both commercial and governmental implementations ($n=140$) and compared them to those employed in academic research. We also propose a high-level taxonomy for DP configuration, capturing practical implementations of differentially private Machine Learning (ML) and Federated Learning (FL) applications, highlighting key factors, including the privacy unit and$\varepsilon$. Our results show that, on average,$\varepsilon$values utilized in the industry span a wider range than those in academic research, with distinct configuration policies for governmental and commercial organizations. Moreover, we identified contrasting reasoning behind$\varepsilon$selection across deployment environments, alongside insufficient transparency in industry disclosures of DP parameters and limited support for user-oriented configuration. Finally, we discuss how the collected knowledge can be used to create methodological guidelines for the configuration of DP in real-world environments, supporting the vision of an Epsilon Registry.

Differential Privacy Configurations in the Real World: A Comparative Analysis

Michael Khavkin and Eran Toch

IEEE Transactions on Knowledge and Data Engineering

37(11)

2025

Android apps typically include many functionalities that not all users require. These result in software bloat that increases possible attack surface and app size. Common functionalities that users may not require are related to permissions that they intend to disallow in the first place. As these permissions are disallowed, their related code would never be executed and therefore can be safely removed. Existing work has proposed a solution to debloat Android apps according to the disallowed permissions. However, for large and complex applications, the debloating process could take hours, typically due the long time that may be needed to construct call graph for analysis. In this work, we propose MiniAppPerm, that speeds up the permission-based debloating by constructing a partial call graph instead of a complete call graph. Our preliminary experiments on a set of apps in Google Play show that MiniAppPerm can reduce the call graph construction time by up to 85.3%. We also checked that the debloated apps can run without crashes.

Towards Speedy Permission-Based Debloating for Android Apps

Ferdian Thung, Jiakun Liu, Pattarakrit Rattanukul, Shahar Maoz, Eran Toch, Debin Gao, David Lo

Proceedings of the IEEE/ACM 11th International Conference on Mobile Software Engineering and Systems

​

2024

The size of Android applications is getting larger to fulfill the requirements of various users. However, not all the features of the applications are needed and desired by a specific user. The unnecessary and non-desired features can increase the attack surface and consume system resources such as storage and memory. To address this issue, we propose a framework, MiniMon, to debloat unnecessary features from an Android app based on the logs of specific users' interactions with the app.

MiniMon: Minimizing Android Applications with Intelligent Monitoring-Based Debloating

Liu Jiakun, Zicheng Zhang, Xing Hu, Ferdian Thung, Shahar Maoz, Debin Gao, Eran Toch, Zhipeng Zhao, and David Lo

IEEE/ACM 46th International Conference on Software Engineering (ICSE)

​

2024

Disengagement from social media platforms encompasses various behaviours, such as reducing activity or abandoning them altogether. At the far end of this spectrum, permanently deleting user accounts holds substantial implications for individuals, the people they contact, and the platform itself. However, the motivations underlying this choice, which involves erasing all content and social connections rather than simply abandoning the platform, remain unclear. To address this research gap, we analysed 4.5 million active users on Tumblr, a microblogging service. We assessed the likelihood of users deleting their accounts using binary logistic regression in general and in specific clusters of users. Our findings reveal that users are more inclined to delete their accounts if they have previously removed content from their profiles, highlighting the role of account deletion in cleaning and controlling personal information. Additionally, we observed robust peer correlations, indicating that users are more likely to delete their accounts if those they follow have already taken this step. We discuss these findings in the context of non-use theories and propose the development of checking-out processes that can enhance the user experience associated with account deletion.

Cleaning house or quiet quitting? Large-scale analysis of account deletion behaviour on Tumblr

Ruth Sarig, Ran Wolff, Eran Toch

Behaviour & Information Technology

44(9)

2024

With ChatGPT’s rapid adoption, concerns regarding generative artificial intelligence (AI) have shifted from theoretical to practical. Drawing upon the “algorithmic imaginary” framework from critical algorithm studies and the anthropological concept of “ordinary ethics,” we analyzed Twitter discourse during ChatGPT’s initial deployment, examining 368,359 tweets. Our analysis identified five topics reflecting functional and critical aspects of ChatGPT. We specifically point to two topics with a critical perspective: “Ethics” and “Concerns.” The first aligns with scholarly discussions in AI ethics on fairness and transparency, while the second focuses on ChatGPT’s generative capabilities. This highlights an emerging trend: While the academic discussion on AI ethics has gained popularity, especially in scrutinizing ChatGPT, the conversation is now expanding to more nuanced ethical deliberations. We analyzed the posts’ engagement and sentiment over time, demonstrating the AI ethics community’s influence in addressing the potential and harms of generative AI systems.

ChatGPT in the Public Eye: Ethical Principles and Generative Concerns in Social Media Discussions

Maayan Roichman, Michael Khavkin, Danielle Movsowitz Davidow, and Eran Toch

New Media and Society

28(1)

2024

Human attention has become a critical resource for the effective design of smart services in which control may move back and forth between humans and computers. To avoid errors in critical conditions when the mental load is high, computer systems need to manage ongoing interruptions. In particular, the effect of interruptions can be mitigated with previews of computer-generated notifications. While previews have been used to increase engagement, research on their potential to mitigate the effect of interruptions is scarce. Using an experiment based on a game environment with varying task loads, we investigated the effect of previews on mitigating interruptions at several levels of mental load. We found interruptions that displayed previews added less to participants’ mental load but did not improve their overall performance. These results were consistent in all levels of task load. We summarize the article by discussing how previews can be designed to minimize the negative effects of interruptions.

Can previews mitigate the effect of interruptions? Findings from a lab experiment under various workloads

Frank John Bolton, Dov Te’eni, and Eran Toch

International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction

40(4)

2024

Product managers are central figures in digital product development, coordinating teams and prioritizing features. Despite their influence, little research explores how their decisions affect user experience, especially in integrating social values into product architecture. Employing a mixed-methods framework, we conducted semi-structured interviews with 20 product managers and an online survey with an additional 81, all based in Israel. Our study identifies four unique strategies product managers utilize to balance business goals, user satisfaction, and ethical considerations. The survey data further substantiates the prevalence of these strategies across diverse sectors, confirming they reflect industry-wide approaches in the Israeli tech sector rather than isolated practices. To conclude, we emphasize how “soft resistance” tactics, such as adjusting data interpretations based on personal values, impact digital product designs. Moreover, our findings highlight that maintaining an ethical reputation in the job market can be pivotal in shaping product design.

Strategies of Product Managers: Negotiating Social Values in Digital Product Design

Eilat Lev Ari, Maayan Roichman, Eran Toch

Proceedings of the CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems

​

2024

People regularly rely on social support from family, friends, and the public when mitigating security and privacy risks, even if mainstream technologies hardly support these interactions. In this paper, we evaluated Meerkat, a mobile application that allows users to receive support through screenshot capturing, marking, and messaging. In a field experiment (n = 65), we tested how Meerkat helps users face phishing attempts and examined it by receiving help from close social connections and community volunteers. Our findings show that while users could learn from both types of helpers, they were significantly more willing to rely on advice from close connections. We evaluate several criteria for successful support interactions, showing that learning is significantly correlated with specific properties of the support interaction, such as the length of the messages. We conclude the paper by discussing how our findings can be used to design community-based applications.

Social Support for Mobile Security: Comparing Close Connections and Community Volunteers in a Field Experiment

Tamir Mendel, and Eran Toch

Proceedings of theCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems

​

2023

Android applications are getting bigger with an increasing number of features. However, not all the features are needed by a specific user. The unnecessary features can increase the attack surface and cost additional resources (e.g., storage and memory). Therefore, it is important to remove unnecessary features from Android applications. However, it is difficult for the end users to fully explore the apps to identify the unnecessary features, and there is no off-the-shelf tool available to assist users to debloat the apps by themselves. In this work, we propose AutoDebloater to debloat Android applications automatically for end users. AutoDebloater is a web application that can be accessed by end-users through a web browser. In particular, AutoDebloater can automatically explore an app and identify the transitions between activities. Then, AutoDebloater will present the Activity Transition Graph to users and ask them to select the activities they do not want to keep. Finally, AutoDebloater will remove the activities that are selected by users from the app. We conducted a user study on five Android apps downloaded from three categories (i.e., Finance, Tools, and Navigation) in Google Play and F-Droid. The results show that users are satisfied with AutoDebloater in terms of the stability of the debloated apps and the ability of AutoDebloater to identify features that are never noticed before. The tool is available at http://autodebloater.club. The code is available at https://github.com/jiakun-liu/autodebloater/ and the demonstration video can be found at https://youtu.be/Gmz0-p2n9D4.

AutoDebloater: Automated Android App Debloating

Jiakun Liu, Hu Xing, Thung Ferdian, Shahar Maoz, Eran Toch, Debin Gao, and David Lo

38th IEEE/ACM International Conference on Automated Software Engineering (ASE)

​

2023

Differential Privacy (DP) is often presented as a strong privacy-enhancing technology with broad applicability and advocated as a de-facto standard for releasing aggregate statistics on sensitive data. However, in many embodiments, DP introduces a new attack surface: a malicious entity entrusted with releasing statistics could manipulate the results and use the randomness of DP as a convenient smokescreen to mask its nefariousness. Since revealing the random noise would obviate the purpose of introducing it, the miscreant may have a perfect alibi. To close this loophole, we introduce the idea of \textit{Verifiable Differential Privacy}, which requires the publishing entity to output a zero-knowledge proof that convinces an efficient verifier that the output is both DP and reliable. Such a definition might seem unachievable, as a verifier must validate that DP randomness was generated faithfully without learning anything about the randomness itself. We resolve this paradox by carefully mixing private and public randomness to compute verifiable DP counting queries with theoretical guarantees and show that it is also practical for real-world deployment. We also demonstrate that computational assumptions are necessary by showing a separation between information-theoretic DP and computational DP under our definition of verifiability.

Privacy-Preserving Payment System With Verifiable Local Differential Privacy

Danielle Movsowitz-Davidow, Yacov Manevich, and Eran Toch

5th Conference on Advances in Financial Technologies (AFT)

​

2023

Android applications are getting bigger with an increasing number of features. However, not all the features are needed by a specific user. The unnecessary features can increase the attack surface and cost additional resources (e.g., storage and memory). Therefore, it is important to remove unnecessary features from Android applications. However, it is difficult for the end users to fully explore the apps to identify the unnecessary features, and there is no off-the-shelf tool available to assist users to debloat the apps by themselves. In this work, we propose AutoDebloater to debloat Android applications automatically for end users. AutoDebloater is a web application that can be accessed by end-users through a web browser. In particular, AutoDebloater can automatically explore an app and identify the transitions between activities. Then, AutoDebloater will present the Activity Transition Graph to users and ask them to select the activities they do not want to keep. Finally, AutoDebloater will remove the activities that are selected by users from the app. We conducted a user study on five Android apps downloaded from three categories (i.e., Finance, Tools, and Navigation) in Google Play and F-Droid. The results show that users are satisfied with AutoDebloater in terms of the stability of the debloated apps and the ability of AutoDebloater to identify features that are never noticed before. The tool is available at http://autodebloater.club. The code is available at https://github.com/jiakun-liu/autodebloater/ and the demonstration video can be found at https://youtu.be/Gmz0-p2n9D4.

AutoDebloater: Automated Android App Debloating

Liu Jiakun, Xing Hu, Ferdian Thung, Shahar Maoz, Eran Toch, Debin Gao, and David Lo

38th IEEE/ACM International Conference on Automated Software Engineering (ASE)

​

2023

Employees are often the victims of phishing attacks, posing a threat to both themselves and their organizations. In response, organizations are dedicating resources, time, and employee effort to train staff to identify simulated phishing attacks. However, the real-world effectiveness of these training efforts in large enterprises remains largely unexplored. To address this, we carried out a controlled experiment in an Israeli financial institution with approximately 5,000 employees. The experiment included three simulated phishing emails, and we examined how different factors influence the phishing Click-Through Rate (CTR). Our findings suggest that employees are more likely to engage with phishing simulation emails that use personalized phrasing. We also found that phishing CTR varies between business units, and that the timing of training before the simulated email did not significantly affect phishing CTR. Furthermore, it became clear that training prior to phishing simulations and adopting a data-driven approach that includes process, variable and measure analysis, can enhance organizational awareness of phishing. Although advanced technologies can mitigate some phishing attacks, our research indicates that employee awareness and proactive behavior will continue to play a critical role in the foreseeable future. The paper concludes by providing guidelines to information security officers on establishing effective organizational awareness to prevent phishing attacks.

Evaluating Organizational Phishing Awareness Training on an Enterprise Scale

Doron Hillman, Yaniv Harel, and Eran Toch

Computers & Security

132

2023

During the COVID-19 pandemic, many countries have developed and deployed contact tracing technologies to curb the spread of the disease by locating and isolating people who have been in contact with coronavirus carriers. Subsequently, understanding why people install and use contact tracing apps is becoming central to their effectiveness and impact. This paper analyzes situations where centralized mass surveillance technologies are deployed simultaneously with a voluntary contact tracing mobile app. We use this parallel deployment as a natural experiment that tests how attitudes toward mass deployments affect people's installation of the contact tracing app. Based on a representative survey of Israelis (n=519), our findings show that positive attitudes toward mass surveillance were related to a reduced likelihood of installing contact tracing apps and an increased likelihood of uninstalling them. These results also hold when controlling for privacy concerns about the contact tracing app, attitudes toward the app, trust in authorities, and demographic properties. Similar reasoning may also be relevant for crowding out voluntary participation in data collection systems.

How Mass Surveillance Crowds Out Installations of COVID-19 Contact Tracing Applications

Eran Toch and Oshrat Ayalon

Proc. ACM Hum.-Comput. Interact

7(CSCW1)

2023

Link to publication
Meerkat is a social support app that helps older adults tackle hurdles in interacting with mobile applications by receiving contextual support from friends and family or community volunteers. The app allows users to describe the interaction issue, capture a screenshot, draw, and write queries to helpers who can provide understandable explanations. Meerkat is informed by theories of collective efficacy and aims to reduce the barriers to existing social networks. Given COVID-19 social distancing measures, the design of Meerkat adapts patterns of peer support to situations where the users are not co-located. To users who do not have available social support, the app provides a foundation to receive support from a community of volunteers who are social connections to other users. Meerkat also includes a practice mode, facilitating social learning by presenting users with mobile tasks. We conclude with how Meerkat can contribute to collective and individual efficacy.

Meerkat: A Social Community Support Application for Older Adults

Tamir Mendel and Eran Toch

CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems Extended Abstracts

​

2022

Link to publication
Peer support is a powerful tool in improving the digital literacy of older adults. However, while existing literature investigated reactive support, this paper examines proactive support for mobile safety. To predict moments that users need support, we conducted a user study to measure the severity of mobile scenarios (n=300) and users' attitudes toward receiving support in a specific interaction around safety on a mobile device (n=150). We compared classification methods and showed that the random forest method produces better performance than other regression models. We show that user anxiety, openness to social support, self-efficacy, and security awareness are important factors to predict willingness to receive support. We also explore various age variations in the training sample on moments users need support prediction. We find that training on the youngest population produces inferior results for older adults, and training on the aging population produces poor outcomes for young adults. We illustrate that the composition of age can affect how the sample impacts model performance. We conclude the paper by discussing how our findings can be used to design feasible proactive support applications to provide support at the right moment.

Toward Proactive Support for Older Adults: Predicting the Right Moment for Providing Mobile Safety Help

Tamir Mendel, Roei Schuster, Eran Tromer, and Eran Toch

Proceedings of the ACM on Interactive, Mobile, Wearable and Ubiquitous Technologies

6(1)

2022

Peer support is a powerful tool in improving the digital literacy of older adults. However, while existing literature investigated reactive support, this paper examines proactive support for mobile safety. To predict moments that users need support, we conducted a user study to measure the severity of mobile scenarios (n=300) and users' attitudes toward receiving support in a specific interaction around safety on a mobile device (n=150). We compared classification methods and showed that the random forest method produces better performance than other regression models. We show that user anxiety, openness to social support, self-efficacy, and security awareness are important factors to predict willingness to receive support. We also explore various age variations in the training sample on moments users need support prediction. We find that training on the youngest population produces inferior results for older adults, and training on the aging population produces poor outcomes for young adults. We illustrate that the composition of age can affect how the sample impacts model performance. We conclude the paper by discussing how our findings can be used to design feasible proactive support applications to provide support at the right moment.

Toward Proactive Support for Older Adults: Predicting the Right Moment for Providing Mobile Safety Help

Tamir Mendel, Roei Schuster, Eran Tromer, and Eran Toch

Proceedings of the ACM on Interactive, Mobile, Wearable and Ubiquitous Technologies

6(1)

2022

Evaluating package delivery crowdsourcing using location traces in different population densities

Ayelet Arditi and Eran Toch

Computers, Environment and Urban Systems

96

2022

The growth of electronic commerce generates significant demand for the delivery of personal goods. Crowdsourcing applications have the potential to create more flexible alternatives to existing package-delivery services. However, the success of these applications is strongly related to the strategies of the crowd couriers, which are not well-understood in the current literature. In this paper, we analyzed data from a real-world crowdsourcing application that uses an auction-based mobile app to deliver small packages in urban, suburban, and intra-metropolitan areas. Our analysis reveals the spatial strategies of crowdsourced couriers, which are correlated with delivery pricing and the courier's experience. The couriers with strong relationships with specific customers create ongoing trust relations, which makes deliveries over medium distance routes financially reasonable for those couriers. We discuss how our findings can help to maximize package-delivery markets and crowdsourcing markets in general by supporting the couriers' strategies.

Crowd logistics: Understanding auction-based pricing and couriers’ strategies in crowdsourcing package delivery

Amit Rechavi and Eran Toch

Journal of Intelligent Transportation Systems

26(2)

2022

People’s location data are continuously tracked from various devices and sensors, enabling an ongoing analysis of sensitive information that can violate people’s privacy and reveal confidential information. Synthetic data have been used to generate representative location sequences yet to maintain the users’ privacy. Nonetheless, the privacy-accuracy tradeoff between these two measures has not been addressed systematically. In this article, we analyze the use of different synthetic data generation models for long location sequences, including extended short-term memory networks (LSTMs), Markov Chains (MC), and variable-order Markov models (VMMs). We employ different performance measures, such as data similarity and privacy, and discuss the inherent tradeoff. Furthermore, we introduce other measurements to quantify each of these measures. Based on the anonymous data of 300 thousand cellular-phone users, our work offers a road map for developing policies for synthetic data generation processes. We propose a framework for building data generation models and evaluating their effectiveness regarding those accuracy and privacy measures.

Synthesis of Longitudinal Human Location Sequences: Balancing Utility and Privacy

Maya Benarous, Eran Toch, Irad Ben-Gal

ACM Transactions on Knowledge Discovery from Data (TKDD)

16(6)

2022

Contemporary computing devices subject their users to continuous interruptions that can seriously harm productivity and well-being. Understanding how people react to notifications can provide valuable information in managing undesirable interruptions. We test whether a wearable EEG system can detect interruption decision events. Participants in a lab experiment (n=15) received notifications while carrying out a primary task, at the same time their brain activity was recorded with a wearable EEG system. We show that specific EEG features can distinguish between notifications that interrupt the user's activity and notifications that the user can disregard. Our results demonstrate that wearable EEG can serve as a basis for managing interruptions.

Detecting interruption events using EEG

Frank Bolton, Dov Te’Eni, Neta B. Maimon, and Eran Toch

IEEE 3rd Global Conference on Life Sciences and Technologies (LifeTech)

​

2021

Malicious software (malware) is a challenging cybersecurity threat, as it is often bundled with legitimate software and downloaded by naïv e users. A significant source of malware downloads is via crack websites that are used to circumvent copyright protection mechanisms. Crack websites often change URLs and IPs to avoid automatic detection; however, in many cases, they preserve specific visual designs that signal the website’s function to potential users (such as particular colors, text fonts, shapes, and sizes.). Website design features are numerous, have high dimensionality and complicated interactions, making categorization challenging. This study shows that straightforward machine learning models for cate-gorizing Crack and Malicious websites can considerably benefit from using design features. We report on two experiments based on unbalanced datasets and show that classification by using design features can reach a categorization accuracy of over 90% with an F1-score over 77% in some instances. Finally, we discuss the results in the context of developing intelligent security mechanisms.

Website categorization via design attribute learning

Cohen, Doron, Or Naim, Eran Toch, and Irad Ben-Gal

Computers & Security

107

2021

Nudging Users towards Online Safety using Gamified Environments

Yelena Petrykina, Hadas Schwartz-Chassidim, and Eran Toch

Computers & Security

108

2021

Older adults face increased safety challenges, such as targeted online fraud and phishing, contributing to the growing technological divide between them and younger adults. Social support from family and friends is often the primary way older adults receive help, but it may also lead to reliance on others. We have conducted an exploratory study to investigate older adults' attitudes and experiences related to mobile social support technologies for mobile safety. We interviewed 18 older adults about their existing support experiences and used the think-aloud method to gather data about a prototype for providing social support during mobile safety challenges. Our findings point to the potential of mobile technology to increase older adults' ability to mitigate mobile safety challenges through active learning from close social connections. We discuss how to support technology can address helpers' intolerance and overcome the challenges of physical distance.

An Exploratory Study of Social Support Systems to Help Older Adults in Managing Mobile Safety

Tamir Mendel, Debin Gao, David Lo, Eran Toch

Proceedings of the 23rd International Conference on Mobile Human-Computer Interaction

30(pp)

2021

Privacy-by-Design (PbD) suggests designing the fundamental architecture and features of computing systems with privacy in mind. Although widely adopted by regulatory frameworks, a growing number of critics have questioned whether PbD's focus on compliance with privacy regulation may prevent it from addressing users' specific privacy attitudes and expectations. Motivated to enhance user-centered privacy-by-design processes, we examine what are the consequences of the way privacy questions are framed to crowd users, and how personal characteristics of the crowd users impact their responses. We recruited a total of 665 participants, of which 456 were recruited via Amazon Mechanical Turk (AMT), and 209 were university students. We show that the framing of computing systems' features using data flows results in features' evaluations that are less critical, compared to using descriptions of personal experiences. We also found, based on the student sample, that students with professional engineering experience are less critical than those with no work experience when assessing the features' appropriateness. We discuss how our results can be used to enhance privacy-by-design processes and encourage user-centered privacy engineering.

User-Centered Privacy-by-Design: Evaluating the Appropriateness of Design Prototypes

Oshrat Ayalon, and Eran Toch

International Journal of Human-Computer Studies

154

2021

People's posting behaviors in social networks was perceived as ambiguous, with concerns misaligned with people's public postings. To address this gap, we suggest a model that offers new insights into the relationship between perceptions and actual behaviors. We define a quantitative marker for agility, the frequency in which people update their audience selection when posting information in online social networks, and evaluate the factors that contribute to the variability of agility between different users. We analyzed the posting behavior of Facebook 181 participants, as well as their answers to open and close questions. We find that frequent changes in privacy settings are correlated with high social privacy and with institutional privacy concerns, whereas social concerns were found to be more prominent. Agility was negatively correlated with low public sharing. Our findings show that users use privacy settings to effectively mitigate privacy concerns and desires for creating and strengthening social connections. We discuss how agility can be used to design and to evaluate new user interfaces for managing privacy in social settings.

Selectivity in Posting on Social Networks: The Role of Privacy Concerns, Social Capital, and Technical Literacy

Hadas Schwartz-Chassidim, Oshrat Ayalon, Tamir Mendel, Ron Hirschprung, and Eran Toch

Heliyon

6(2)

2020

Installing security applications is a common way to protect against malicious apps, phishing emails, and other threats in mobile operating systems. While these applications can provide essential security protections, they also tend to access large amounts of people's sensitive information. Therefore, individuals need to evaluate the trade-off between the security features and the privacy invasion when deciding on which protection mechanisms to use. In this paper, we examine factors affecting the willingness to install mobile security applications by taking into account the invasion levels and security features of cyber-security applications. To this end, we propose a visual language that depicts the coverage of different security features as well as privacy intrusiveness levels. Our user study (n=300) shows that users assessing security applications find their trade-off balance in highly secure apps with a medium level of privacy invasion. The results indicate that a low privacy invasion might signal that the security application provides less security. We discuss these findings in the context of understanding the trade-off between privacy and security.

Between privacy and security: the factors that drive intentions to use cyber-security applications

Hadas Schwartz-Chassidim, Christos Perentis, Eran Toch & Bruno Lepri

Behaviour & Information Technology

40(16)

2020

Contemporary mobile devices continuously interrupt people with notifications in various and changing physical environments. As different places can have different social setting, understanding how disturbing an interruption might be to people around the user is not a straightforward task. To understand how users perceive disturbance in their social environment, we analyze the results of a 3-week user study with 50 participants using the experience sampling method and log analysis. We show that perceptions of disturbance are strongly related to the social norms surrounding the place, such as whether the place is considered private or public, even when controlling for the number of people around the user. Furthermore, users' perceptions of disturbance are also related to the activity carried out on the phone, and the subjective perceptions of isolation from other people in the space. We conclude the paper by discussing how our findings can be used to design new mobile devices that are aware of the social norms and their users' environmental context.

Can you Turn it Off? The Spatial and Social Context of Mobile Disturbance

Eran Toch, Hadas Schwartz-Chassidim, and Tali Hatuka

Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction

4(CSCW2)

2020

Analyzing large-scale human mobility data: a survey of machine learning methods and applications,

Eran Toch, Boaz Lerner, Eyal Ben-Zion, and Irad Ben-Gal

Knowledge and Information Systems

58(3)

2019

A/P(rivacy) Testing: Assessing Applications for Social and Institutional Privacy

Oshrat Ayalon and Eran Toch

Extended Abstracts of the 2019 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems

​

2019

Link to publication
Security and privacy pose a serious barrier to the use of mobile technology by older adults. While support from family and friends is known to be an effective enabler in older adults' technology adoption, we know very little about the family members' motivations for providing help, the context, and the process in which they provide it. To bridge this gap, we have conducted a mixed method study, qualitatively analyzing the helpers' assistance stories and quantitatively estimating the factors that affect helpers' willingness to offer assistance to older relatives regarding mobile security and privacy problems. Our findings point to the potential for helping older relatives, i.e., people are more willing to help and guide them than other social groups. Furthermore, we show that familiarity with an older relative's preferences is essential in providing meaningful support. We discuss our findings in the context of developing a theory of collective efficacy for security and privacy and new collaborative technologies that can reduce the barriers to social help.

My Mom was Getting this Popup: Understanding Motivations and Processes in Helping Older Relatives with Mobile Security and Privacy

Tamir Mendel and Eran Toch

ACM Interactive, Mobile, Wearable and Ubiquitous Technologies (IMWUT)

3(4)

2019

The rapid adoption of Smartphone devices has caused increasing security and privacy risks and breaches. Catching up with ever-evolving contemporary smartphone technology challenges leads older adults (aged 50+) to reduce or to abandon their use of mobile technology. To tackle this problem, we present AppMoD, a community-based approach that allows delegation of security and privacy decisions a trusted social connection, such as a family member or a close friend. The trusted social connection can assist in the appropriate decision or make it on behalf of the user. We implement the approach as an Android app and describe the results of three user studies (n=50 altogether), in which pairs of older adults and family members used the app in a controlled experiment. Using app anomalies as an ongoing case study, we show how delegation improves the accuracy of decisions made by older adults. Also, we show how combining decision-delegation with crowdsourcing can enhance the advice given and improve the decision-making process. Our results suggest that a community-based approach can improve the state of mobile security and privacy.

AppMoD: Helping Older Adults Manage Mobile Security with Online Social Help

Zhiyuan Wan, Lingfeng Bao, Debin Gao, Eran Toch, Xin Xia, Tamir Mendel, and David Lo

ACM Interactive, Mobile, Wearable and Ubiquitous Technologies – IMWUT

3(4)

2019

Evaluating Users’ Perceptions about a System’s Privacy: Differentiating Social and Institutional Aspects

Oshrat Ayalon and Eran Toch

Fifteenth Symposium on Usable Privacy and Security (SOUPS)

​

2019

When designed incorrectly, information systems can thwart people’s expectations of privacy. An emerging technique for evaluating systems during the development stage is the crowdsourcing design critique, in which design evaluations are sourced using crowdsourcing platforms. However, we know that information framing has a serious effect on decision-making and can steer design critiques in one way or another. We investigate how the framing of design cases can influence the outcomes of privacy design critiques. Specifically, we test whether -˜Personas’, a central User-Centered Design tool for describing users, can inspire empathy in users while criticizing privacy designs. In an experiment on Amazon Mechanical Turk workers (n=456), we show that describing design cases by using personas causes intrusive designs to be criticized more harshly. We discuss how our results can be used to enhance privacy-by-design processes and encourage user-centered privacy engineering.

Crowdsourcing Privacy Design Critique: An Empirical Evaluation of Framing Effects

Oshrat Ayalon and Eran Toch

The 51st Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences

​

2018

Remembrance of Things Past: Understanding the Time Dimension in Online Social Networks (Hebrew)

Oshrat Ayalon and Eran Toch

Privacy, Law, and the Surveillance Society (A. Likhovski and M. Birnhack, eds.), The Buchman Faculty of Law Series, Law, Society and Culture Series

​

2018

Link to publication

Moving Beyond a 'One-Size Fits All': Exploring Individual Differences in Privacy

Daniel Wilkinson, Moses Namara, Karla Badillo-Urquiola, Pamela J. Wisniewski, Bart P. Knijnenburg, Xinru Page, Eran Toch, and Jen Romano-Bergstrom

Extended Abstracts of the 2018 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems

​

2018

Link to publication
Cyber-security systems, which protect networks and computers against cyber attacks, are becoming common due to increasing threats and government regulation. At the same time, the enormous amount of data gathered by cyber-security systems poses a serious threat to the privacy of the people protected by those systems. To ground this threat, we survey common and novel cyber-security technologies and analyze them according to the potential for privacy invasion. We suggest a taxonomy for privacy risks assessment of information security technologies, based on the level of data exposure, the level of identification of individual users, the data sensitivity and the user control over the monitoring, and collection and analysis of the data. We discuss our results in light of the recent technological trends and suggest several new directions for making these mechanisms more privacy-aware.

The Privacy Implications of Cyber Security Systems: A Technological Survey

Eran Toch, Claudio Bettini, Erez Shmueli, Laura Radaelli, Andrea Lanzi, Daniele Riboni, and Bruno Lepri

ACM Computing Surveys 51-2

2(Article)

2018

Numerous studies have focused on the global city, the sustainable city, the resilient city, the creative city, and the smart city, analyzing their politics, ideologies, and social implications. However, the literature lacks synthetic analysis that addresses these concepts by juxtaposing them and exploring their similarities and differences. This paper provides synthetic analysis, followed by a discussion of the concepts’ competing and complementary logics of governance and citizenship. The concluding section addresses the importance of taking into account these diverse concepts as political ideas and discusses how these concepts become a prescriptive mix promoted by public officials and private developers.

The Political Premises of Contemporary Urban Concepts: The Global City, the Sustainable City, the Resilient City, the Creative City, and the Smart City

Tali Hatuka, Issachar Rosen-Zvi, Michael Birnhack, Eran Toch & Hadas Zur

Planning Theory & Practice

19(2)

2018

Augmented-Genomics: Protecting Privacy for Clinical Genomics with Inferential Interfaces

Eran Toch, Netta Rager, Tomer Florentin, Dan Linenberg, Daniel Sellman, and Noam Shomron

Companion Proceedings of the 23rd International Conference on Intelligent User Interfaces (IUI)

​

2018

Link to publication

Privacy in Context: Critically Engaging with Theory to Guide Privacy Research and Design

Karla Badillo-Urquiola, Yaxing Yao, Oshrat Ayalon, Bart Knijnenburg, Xinru Page, Eran Toch, Yang Wang, and Pamela Wisniewski

Companion of the 2018 ACM Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing (CSCW)

​

2018

Link to publication

Reducing Communication Uncertainty with Social Intelligibility: Challenges and Opportunities

Brian Y. Lim, Oshrat Ayalon, and Eran Toch

CHI 2017 Workshop on Designing for Uncertainty in HCI

​

2017

Link to publication
New technologies continuously challenge people's information privacy, while privacy protection practices, such as Privacy-by-Design, did not become widespread engineering practices. The difficulty of designing privacy-preserving information systems highlights the need for studying developers' privacy decision-making processes, as the developers' communities are well coordinated and they are the ones who can promote or hinder privacy in the systems they design. We conducted an online survey (n=101), to understand the effectors on developers' professional privacy attitudes and practices. We investigate whether developer's privacy decision-making is shaped by several factors, including organizational (organizational privacy climate, business and legal contexts), professional (privacy knowledge) and personal (personal perceived privacy).

How Developers Make Design Decisions about Users' Privacy: The Place of Professional Communities and Organizational Climate

Oshrat Ayalon, Eran Toch, Irit Hadar, and Michael Birnhack

Companion of the 2017 ACM Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing (CSCW)

​

2017

Link to publication

Privacy by designers: software developers’ privacy mindset

Irit Hadar, Tomer Hasson, Oshrat Ayalon, Eran Toch, Michael Birnhack, Sofia Sherman, and Arod Balissa

Em

23(1)

2017

Susceptibility to Social Influence of Privacy Behaviors: Peer versus Authoritative Sources,

Tamir Mendel and Eran Toch

Proceedings of theACM Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing

​

2017

Online social networks (OSNs) make information accessible for unlimited periods and provide easy access to past information by arranging information in time lines or by providing sophisticated search mechanisms. Despite increased concerns over the privacy threat that is posed by digital memory, there is little knowledge about retrospective privacy: the extent to which the age of the exposed information affects sharing preferences. In this article, we investigate how information aging impacts users’ sharing preferences on Facebook. Our findings are based on a between-subjects experiment (n = 272), in which we measured the impact of time since first publishing an OSN post on its sharing preferences. Our results quantify how willingness to share is lower for older Facebook posts and show that older posts have lower relevancy to the user’s social network and are less representative of the user’s identity. We show that changes in the user’s social circles, the occurrence of significant life changes and a user’s young age are correlated with a further decrease in the willingness to keep sharing past information. We discuss our findings by juxtaposing digital memory theories and privacy theories and suggest a vision for mechanisms that can help users manage longitudinal privacy.

Not Even Past: Information Aging and Temporal Privacy in Online Social Networks,

Oshrat Ayalon and Eran Toch

Human–Computer Interaction

32(2)

2017

The way users manage access to their information and computers has a tremendous effect on the overall security and privacy of individuals and organizations. Usually, access management is conducted using a choice architecture , a behavioral economics concept that describes the way decisions are framed to users. Studies have consistently shown that the design of choice architectures, mainly the selection of default options, has a strong effect on the final decisions users make by nudging them toward certain behaviors. In this article, we propose a method for optimizing access control choice architectures in online social networks. We empirically evaluate the methodology on Facebook, the world's largest online social network, by measuring how well the default options cover the existing user choices and preferences and toward which outcome the choice architecture nudges users. The evaluation includes two parts: (a) collecting access control decisions made by 266 users of Facebook for a period of 3 months; and (b) surveying 533 participants who were asked to express their preferences regarding default options. We demonstrate how optimal defaults can be algorithmically identified from users’ decisions and preferences, and we measure how existing defaults address users’ preferences compared with the optimal ones. We analyze how access control defaults can better serve existing users, and we discuss how our method can be used to establish a common measuring tool when examining the effects of default options.

Analyzing and Optimizing Access Control Choice Architectures in Online Social Networks

Ron Hirschprung, Eran Toch, Hadas Schwartz-Chassidim, Tamir Mendel, and Oded Maimon

ACM Transactions on Intelligent Systems and Technology (TIST)

8(4)

2017

Link to publication
Over recent decades, cities have been radically transformed by information and communication technologies (ICTs) that modify people’s daily lives by reorganising mobility, infrastructure systems and physical spaces. However, in addition to the role that technology plays in the development of the infrastructure in our cities, it is also being used ‘as a means of control’. This view of technology as a disciplinary tool that restructures space, time and the relations among activities has been promoted by scholars who have shown that technology is also a means of saturating and sustaining contemporary capitalist societies and deepening inequalities. However, the situation is far more complex than that. Technology is not only used top-down but also bottom-up, with individuals using technological devices to share and enhance their visibility in space. This bidirectional paradigm – of vertical surveillance and horizontal sharing – contributes to a sense of ‘being exposed’ in public space that normalises practices of sharing personal data by individuals and thus results in diminished privacy. This argument is supported by an experiment conducted on smartphone users that includes personal interviews and the use of a smartphone Android application that combines online tracking with experience sampling. The findings show a convergence between the online and offline worlds (a ‘public’ situation in the offline world is also considered as such in the online world), which is a condition that contributes to the normalisation of ‘asymmetrical visibility’. Based on these results, the paper ends with a discussion of the contemporary meaning of public space.

Being Visible in Public Space: The Normalization of Asymmetrical Visibility

Tali Hatuka and Eran Toch

Urban Studies

54(4)

2017

The exchange of private information for services or other benefits is a commonplace practice today in the advent of mobile technology. In the case of mobile services, the exchanged commodity is increasingly often spatial location of the user. To decide whether this transaction is beneficial, the user needs to evaluate the exchange value of this commodity. To assess the value users give to their location, and to understand its relationship with location sharing, we conducted a study on a mobile crowdsourcing platform (N=190). We find that users' valuation of location privacy is dependent on the sharing scenario. For instance, when the location is to be shared with an untrusted advertiser, the users require a premium as compensation for their information. Additionally, benefit perception and trust are found to be connected with more frequent location sharing, while perceived risks and privacy concern are associated with sharing one’s location less frequently.

Understanding the Valuation of Location Privacy: a Crowdsourcing-Based Approach

Maija Poikela and Eran Toch

Proceedings of the 50th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences

​

2017

A methodology for estimating the value of privacy in information disclosure systems

Ron Hirschprung, Eran Toch, Frank Bolton, and Oded Maimon

Computers in Human Behavior

61(pp)

2016

Anonymizing Mobility Data using Semantic Cloaking

Omer Barak, Gabriella Cohen, and Eran Toch

Pervasive and Mobile Computing

28(pp)

2016

This paper underscores the centrality of individual technological devices, particularly mobile phones, in structuring contemporary social interaction in public spaces. It illustrates the need to re-think the relationship between information and communications technologies and practices of sociability in public spaces. Based on surveys of users of mobile phones (basic mobile phones and smartphones), we explore the practices and actions of subjects in public spaces. Empirical analysis shows that the use of mobile phones and, particularly, smartphones, is gradually modifying the normative constraints associated with place and social codes, simultaneously enhancing both a sense of freedom and estrangement. Based on our findings, the paper suggests the concept of portable private-personal territory to better understand the personal space individuals develop with the support of technology. Finally, the paper concludes with a reflection on the future implications of portable private-personal territories for public spaces and cities.

The emergence of portable private-personal territory (PPPT): Smartphones, social conduct and public spaces.

Tali Hatuka and Eran Toch

Urban Studies

53(10)

2016

Location-based social network apps for dating have grown significantly over the past few years. Although they have many possible uses, casual and sexual encounters remain an important part of their draw. For CSCW, these apps are interesting to study: they offer a context to explore issues of identity and self-presentation, geography and locality, privacy and security, as well as motivation and usage habits. In this one-day workshop, we invite researchers, students, and practitioners from a diverse range of backgrounds, including CSCW, computer science, sociology, and public health, to discuss these issues and more, as well as to explore the difficulties and challenges inherent in this research. In addition to exploring the issues around apps for sex and dating, participants will also help to bring some of these sensitive, yet important topics into the mainstream of CSCW research.

Let's Talk About Sex (Apps)

Jeremy Birnholtz, Irina Shklovski, Mark Handel, and Eran Toch

Proceedings of the 18th ACM Conference Companion on Computer Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing (CSCW)

​

2015

Link to publication
Cloud computing offers a compelling vision of computation, enabling an unprecedented level of data distribution and sharing. Beyond improving the computing infrastructure, cloud computing enables a higher level of interoperability between information systems, simplifying tasks such as sharing documents between coworkers or enabling collaboration between an organization and its suppliers. While these abilities may result in significant benefits to users and organizations, they also present privacy challenges due to unwanted exposure of sensitive information. As information-sharing processes in cloud computing are complex and domain specific, configuring these processes can be an overwhelming and burdensome task for users. This article investigates the feasibility of configuring sharing processes through a small and representative set of canonical configuration options. For this purpose, we present a generic method, named SCON-UP (Simplified CON-figuration of User Preferences). SCON-UP simplifies configuration interfaces by using a clustering algorithm that analyzes a massive set of sharing preferences and condenses them into a small number of discrete disclosure levels. Thus, the user is provided with a usable configuration model while guaranteeing adequate privacy control. We describe the algorithm and empirically evaluate our model using data collected in two user studies (n = 121 and n = 352). Our results show that when provided with three canonical configuration options, on average, 82% of the population can be covered by at least one option. We exemplify the feasibility of discretizing sharing levels and discuss the tradeoff between coverage and simplicity in discrete configuration options.

Simplifying Data Disclosure Configurations in a Cloud Computing Environment

Ron Hirschprung, Eran Toch and Oded Maimon

ACM Transactions on Intelligent Systems and Technology

6(3)

2015

Crowdsourcing Privacy Preferences in Context-Aware Applications

Eran Toch

Personal and Ubiquitous Computing

18(1)

2014

Are Designers Ready for Privacy by Design? Examining Perceptions of Privacy Among Information Systems Designers,

Tomer Hasson, Irit Hadar, Oshrat Ayalon, Sofia Sherman, Eran Toch, and Michael Birnhack

42nd Research Conference on Communication, Information and Internet Policy, Washington D.C

​

2014

Policymakers around the world constantly search for new tools to address growing concerns as to informational privacy (data protection). One solution that has gained support in recent years among policy makers is Privacy by Design (PbD). The idea is simple: think of privacy ex ante, and embed privacy within the design of a new technological system, rather than try to fix it ex post, when it is often too late. However, PbD is yet to gain an active role in engineering practices. Thus far, there are only a few success stories. We argue that a major obstacle for PbD is the discursive and conceptual gap between law and technology. A better diagnosis of the gaps between the legal and technological perceptions of privacy is a crucial step in seeking viable solutions. We juxtapose the two fields by reading each field in terms of the other field. We reverse engineer the law, so as to expose its hidden assumptions about technology (the law’s technological mindset), and we read canonical technological texts, so as to expose their hidden assumptions about privacy (technology’s privacy mindset). Our focus is on one set of informational privacy practices: the large corporation that collects data from individual data subjects. This dual reverse engineering indicates substantial gaps between the legal perception of informational privacy, as reflected in the set of principles commonly known as Fair Information Privacy Principles (FIPPs) and the perceptions of the engineering community. While both information technology and privacy law attempt to regulate the flow of data, they do so in utterly different ways, holding different goals and applying different constraints. The gaps between law and technology point to potential avenues to save PbD.

Privacy Mindset, Technological Mindset,

Michael Birnhack, Eran Toch, and Irit Hadar

Jurimetrics

55(114)

2014

In many online services, users are asked to configure their privacy settings by choosing between a small set of initial privacy options. For example, in Facebook, the world’s largest online social network, users can choose between three default privacy settings: sharing their profile and posts with their Facebook friends, their friends-of-friends, or with the general public (which is selected by default.) Research in human-computer interaction and in economics has repeatedly shown that reducing options and prescribing default options have a profound and lasting affect on users’ ongoing behavior, pushing users to the prescribed set of options. It is not surprising that default choices are lately the subject of legislation attempts, aiming to regulate the option selection and default selections in online services. For example, the California bill S.B. 242, required web sites to establish a default privacy setting that prohibits the display of most personally identifiable information. In light of this regulatory trend, it is becoming crucial to better understand the nature of reducing the set of privacy options or prescribing default options. This study takes an algorithmic approach to analyzing default privacy options in online services. We suggest and evaluate an assessment method that analyzes the service’s default options, by comparing them to the actual preferences of a sample of people who already use the service. The assessment is based on a set of indicators that measure the extent to which the default options reflect the users’ preferences and behaviors. The indicators can be used to analyze the options, providing designers and policy makers with tools that evaluate how well a set of options can fairly serve a given population. First, we look at how representative the default options. We calculate the proportion of the population that would be satisfied by at least one of the options, and measure how different default options and selections impact that proportion. Second, we look at the social welfare that different default options can provide to the user population, with regard to how well the options match the users’ preferences. We analyze measures of disparity between users’ preferences, and define formal notions of equality and fairness. Finally, we suggest methods for deriving an optimal set of default options, which satisfy the largest proportion of users with the highest possible matching quality. We empirically evaluate our assessment using data collected from Facebook, describing the detailed privacy behavior of about 400 Facebook users. We analyze the users’ privacy preferences, and validate it using external resources and surveys regarding Facebook usage. We then evaluate Facebook’s existing default privacy settings, as well as other popular privacy configurations in Facebook, against the users’ actual behavior. The findings of this research formally and mathematically describe the inherent bias in the current default privacy settings offered by online service providers. We demonstrate how our methods can be used to evaluate default privacy options, to analyze them, and to synthesize representative options that maximize users’ social welfare.

An Algorithmic Approach To Evaluating Default Privacy Options,

Ron Hirshpung, Hadas Scwartz-Hassidim, and Eran Toch

42nd Research Conference on Communication, Information and Internet Policy, Washington D.C

​

2014

Retrospective Privacy: Managing Longitudinal Privacy in Online Social Networks

Oshrat Ayalon and Eran Toch

Proceedings of the Ninth Symposium on Usable Privacy and Security (SOUPS ’13)

2013(4)

2013

People-Nearby applications are becoming a popular way for individuals to search for new social relations in their physical vicinity. This paper presents the results of a qualitative study, based on 25 interviews, examining how privacy and locality are managed in these applications. We describe how location is used as a grounding mechanism, providing a platform for honest and truthful signals in the challenging process of forming new social relations. We discuss our findings by suggesting theoretical frameworks that can be used to analyze the social space induced by the applications, as well as to inform the design of new technologies that foster the creation of new social ties.

Locality and Privacy in People-Nearby Applications.

Eran Toch and Inbal Levi

Proceedings of theACM international joint conference on Pervasive and ubiquitous computing (UbiComp ’13). ACM, New York, NY, USA

​

2013

The Price is Right? Economic Value of Location Sharing.

Omer Barak, Gabriella Cohen, Alla Gazit, and Eran Toch. 2013

Proceedings of theACM conference on Pervasive and ubiquitous computing adjunct publication (UbiComp ’13 Adjunct). ACM, New York, NY, USA

​

2013

Ubiquitous commerce (u-commerce) represents "anytime, anywhere" commerce. U-commerce can provide a high level of personalization, which can bring significant benefits to customers. However, privacy is a major concern to customers and an obstacle to the adoption of u-commerce. This research examines how personalization and context can impact customers' privacy concerns as well as intention to adopt u-commerce applications. As u-commerce is new and emerging, we used the scenario-based approach to operationalize personalization and context in an experimental study. The experimental results show that the effects of personalization on customers' privacy concerns and adoption intention are situation dependent.

Personalization and Privacy.

Eran Toch, Yang Wang, and Lorrie Faith Cranor

User Modeling and User-Adapted Interaction (UMUAI)

22(1)

2012

OPOSSUM: indexing techniques for an order-of-magnitude improvement of service matchmaking times

Eran Toch

Semantic Services: Advancement through Evaluation (Blake, Cabral, Konig-Ries, Kuster, Martin, eds.)

62(Springer)

2012

Super-Ego: a framework for privacy-sensitive bounded context-awareness.

Eran Toch

Proceedings of the 5th ACM International Workshop on Context-Awareness for Self-Managing Systems (CASEMANS ’11). Best paper award

​

2011

Humans, Semantics Services and Similarity: A User Study of Semantic Web Services Matching and Composition.

Eran Toch, Iris Reinhartz-Berger, Dov Dori

Journal of Web Semantics

9(1)

2011

Who’s your best friend?: targeted privacy attacks In location-sharing social networks

Vassilis Kostakos, Jayant Venkatanathan, Bernardo Reynolds, Norman Sadeh, Eran Toch, Siraj A. Shaikh, and Simon Jones

Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Ubiquitous Computing (UbiComp ’11)

​

2011

Improving Users’ Consistency When Recalling Location Sharing Preferences

Jayant Venkatanathan, Denzil Ferreira, Michael Benisch, Jialiu Lin, Evangelos Karapanos, Vassilis Kostakos, Norman M. Sadeh, Eran Toch

Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Human-Computer Interaction (INTERACT ’11)

​

2011

This paper examines the location traces of 489 users of a location sharing social network for relationships between the users' mobility patterns and structural properties of their underlying social network. We introduce a novel set of location-based features for analyzing the social context of a geographic region, including location entropy, which measures the diversity of unique visitors of a location. Using these features, we provide a model for predicting friendship between two users by analyzing their location trails. Our model achieves significant gains over simpler models based only on direct properties of the co-location histories, such as the number of co-locations. We also show a positive relationship between the entropy of the locations the user visits and the number of social ties that user has in the network. We discuss how the offline mobility of users can have implications for both researchers and designers of online social networks.

Bridging the gap between physical location and online social networks,

Justin Cranshaw, Eran Toch, Jason Hong, Aniket Kittur, Norman Sadeh

proceedings of the 12th ACM international conference on Ubiquitous computing (Ubicomp ’10)

​

2010

Locaccino: A Privacy-Centric Location Sharing Application

Eran Toch, Justin Cranshaw, Paul Hankes-Drielsma, Jay Springfield, Patrick Gage Kelley, Lorrie Cranor, Jason Hong, and Norman Sadeh

Proceedings of the 12th ACM International Conference Adjunct Papers on Ubiquitous Computing

​

2010

Link to publication
Default privacy policies have a significant impact on the overall dynamics and success of online social networks, as users tend to keep their initial privacy policies. In this work-in-progress, we present a new method for suggesting privacy policies for new users by exploring knowledge of existing policies. The defaults generation process performs a collaborative analysis of the policies, finding personalized and representative suggestions. We show how the process can be extended to a wide range of domains, and present results based on 543 privacy policies obtained from a live location-based social network. Finally, we present a user interaction model that lets the user retain control over the default policies, allowing the user to make knowledgeable decisions regarding which default policy to take.

Generating Default Privacy Policies for Online Social Networks

Eran Toch, Norman M. Sadeh, and Jason Hong

CHI '10 Extended Abstracts on Human Factors in Computing Systems

​

2010

Link to publication
The rapid adoption of location tracking and mobile social networking technologies raises significant privacy challenges. Today our understanding of people's location sharing privacy preferences remains very limited, including how these preferences are impacted by the type of location tracking device or the nature of the locations visited. To address this gap, we deployed Locaccino, a mobile location sharing system, in a four week long field study, where we examined the behavior of study participants (n=28) who shared their location with their acquaintances (n=373.) Our results show that users appear more comfortable sharing their presence at locations visited by a large and diverse set of people. Our study also indicates that people who visit a wider number of places tend to also be the subject of a greater number of requests for their locations. Over time these same people tend to also evolve more sophisticated privacy preferences, reflected by an increase in time- and location-based restrictions. We conclude by discussing the implications our findings.

Empirical models of privacy in location sharing

Eran Toch, Justin Cranshaw, Paul Hankes Drielsma, Janice Y. Tsai, Patrick Gage Kelley, James Springfield, Lorrie Cranor, Jason Hong, and Norman Sadeh

Proceedings of the 12th ACM international conference on Ubiquitous computing

​

2010

In this work, we propose a two-step, context-based semantic approach to the problem of matching and ranking Web services for possible service composition. We present an analysis of different methods for classifying Web services for possible composition and supply a context-based semantic matching method for ranking these possibilities. Semantic understanding of Web services may provide added value by identifying new possibilities for compositions of services. The semantic matching ranking approach is unique since it provides the Web service designer with an explicit numeric estimation of the extent to which a possible composition ldquomakes sense.rdquo First, we analyze two common methods for text processing, TF/IDF and context analysis; and two types of service description, free text and WSDL. Second, we present a method for evaluating the proximity of services for possible compositions. Each Web service WSDL context descriptor is evaluated according to its proximity to other services' free text context descriptors. The methods were tested on a large repository of real-world Web services. The experimental results indicate that context analysis is more useful than TF/IDF. Furthermore, the method evaluating the proximity of the WSDL description to the textual description of other services provides high recall and precision results.

Context-Based Matching and Ranking of Web Services for Composition

Eran Toch, Avigdor Gal, Aviv Segev

IEEE Transactions on Services Computing

99(1)

2009

In this work we provide an initial analysis of service categorization, the process of associating services with ontologies. Service categorization is an important pre-processing step to tasks such as service composition. The absence of semantic understanding of services may yield erroneous compositions and therefore, service categorization can assist in determining the correctness of a composition. We analyze two common methods for text processing, TF/IDF and context analysis. We also test two types of service description, textual and WSDL. Our initial results indicate that context analysis is more useful than TF/IDF and that WSDL description provides better categorization than textual description. 1.

Semantic Methods for Service Categorization: An Empirical Study

Avigdor Gal, Aviv Segev, and Eran Toch

Proceedings of the VLDB International Workshop on Semantic Data and Service Integration

​

2007

Link to publication
Web service discovery is one of the main applications of semantic Web services, which extend standard Web services with semantic annotations. Current discovery solutions were developed in the context of automatic service composition. Thus, the “client” of the discovery procedure is an automated computer program rather than a human, with little, if any, tolerance to inexact results. However, in the real world, services which might be semantically distanced from each other are glued together using manual coding. In this article, we propose a new retrieval model for semantic Web services, with the objective of simplifying service discovery for human users. The model relies on simple and extensible keyword-based query language and enables efficient retrieval of approximate results, including approximate service compositions. Since representing all possible compositions and all approximate concept references can result in an exponentially-sized index, we investigate clustering methods to provide a scalable mechanism for service indexing. Results of experiments, designed to evaluate our indexing and query methods, show that satisfactory approximate search is feasible with efficient processing time.

A Semantic Approach to Approximate Service Retrieval

Eran Toch, Avigdor Gal, Iris Reinhartz-Berger, and Dov Dori

ACM Transactions on Internet Technology

8(1)

2007

This paper describes a Web-based and distributed system named QSIA that serves as an environment for learning, assessing and knowledge sharing. QSIA - Questions Sharing and Interactive Assignments-offers a unified infrastructure for developing, collecting, managing and sharing of knowledge items. QSIA enhances collaboration in authoring via online recommendations and generates communities of teachers and learners. At the same time, QSIA fosters individual learning and might promote high-order thinking skills among its users. QSIA's community, conceptual architecture, structure overview and implementations are discussed.

QSIA – a web-based environment for learning, assessing and knowledge sharing in communities

Sheizaf Rafaeli, Miri Barak, Yuval Dan-Gur, and Eran Toch

Computers & Education

43(3)

2004

2026

wolfson1.jpg

Contact Us

The lab is located at the Faculty of Engineering, in the Wolfson building for Mechanical Engineering, in the School of Industrial & Intelligent Systems Engineering. To reach our building, enter the campus through Gate 14 on Klausner St., Gate 4 (always open) on George Wise St., or Gate 17. The Wolfson building is marked on the map below. You can also find it as building 34 on the official TAU map.

Chaim Levanon St 30 (Dr. George Wise Street for postal correspondence), Tel Aviv-Yafo, 6997801, Israel

Thanks for submitting!

© 2023 by Tel Aviv University. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page